IR Solutions

Email Marketing for Pet Stores: Bring Customers Back for Their Next Order

6 min read
ammar basit

Written by

ammar basit

SEO Content Specialist

Ammar is a content writer who specializes in digital marketing, staff augmentation, and business technology. He creates SEO-friendly blog posts and informative articles that help businesses share valuable insights and reach the right audience. His writing focuses on clear, practical, and well-researched content that improves search visibility, builds brand authority, and keeps readers informed about the latest industry trends.

Stay connected

Follow IR Solutions

Email Marketing for Pet Stores: Bring Customers Back for Their Next Order
Article Content
  1. Where Online Pet Stores Lose Their Next Sale
  2. Build Your Email Strategy Around What Customers Buy
  3. 10 Email Marketing Strategies to Increase Repeat Orders for Pet Stores
  4. Pet Store Email Marketing Examples
  5. Pet Store Email Campaign Ideas for Every Season
  6. How to Measure Whether Your Emails Are Bringing Customers Back
  7. Generate More Repeat Orders With IR Solutions
  8. Conclusion
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

Key Takeaways

  • Send reorder reminders before customers run out of their regular pet supplies.
  • Use purchase history to recommend products that match each customer's needs.
  • Segment customers by pet type, product category, and previous buying habits.
  • Give subscribers flexible delivery options to reduce cancellations and missed orders.
  • Track repeat purchases, reorder revenue, and subscription retention to measure results.

Getting a customer to buy dog food once is good. Getting them to order again is even better. If another store offers faster delivery when their food runs out, you could lose that customer.

Email marketing helps you bring customers back before they need to shop elsewhere. A simple reorder reminder or relevant product suggestion can encourage another purchase.

Use past orders to make your emails more useful. Consider the product, size, quantity, and purchase date. A customer buying large bags of dog food may need reminders at different times than someone buying cat litter.

This guide covers reorder reminders, product suggestions, repeat purchase emails, and the key metrics to track.

Where Online Pet Stores Lose Their Next Sale

Pet owners often shop wherever they can get their usual food or litter before it runs out. Even if their first order went smoothly, a late reminder or a faster delivery option can send them elsewhere.

  • Missed Reorders: Customers buy elsewhere when food or litter runs out before your reminder arrives.
  • Marketplace Competition: Saved payment details and faster delivery make marketplaces an easy choice.
  • Irrelevant Promotions: Cat owners may start ignoring your emails if you keep promoting dog food.
  • Discount Dependency: Frequent vouchers teach customers to wait for a deal before ordering again.
  • Subscription Cancellations: Customers may cancel when deliveries arrive faster than their pets use the products.

Check when customers usually reorder and what they tell you when they contact support or cancel. If subscribers keep saying they have unopened bags at home, give them an easy way to delay their next delivery.

Build Your Email Strategy Around What Customers Buy

A customer buying dog food may need a reorder reminder, while someone buying a pet bed may need washing instructions. The item tells you what the buyer might need next and gives you a practical starting point for timing. These example cycles are planning estimates, so check them against your own orders before scheduling any automatic messages.

Product Category

Example Purchase Cycle

Recommended Email

Pet food

2–6 weeks

Replenishment reminder

Cat litter

2–4 weeks

Restock reminder

Pet supplements

Based on pack duration

Reorder reminder

Dog treats

Based on consumption

Replenishment and bundle offers

Grooming products

1–3 months

Product replacement reminder

Toys

Variable

New arrivals and related products

Collars and harnesses

Several months or longer

Complementary product recommendations

Pet beds

Long purchase cycle

Accessories and cross-selling

Use the median time between orders for the same product and pack size to schedule your first reminder. If you have little order history, let customers choose a reminder date that suits how quickly they use each pack.

For pet ecommerce customer retention, start with products customers already reorder, such as food and litter. Keep prices and pack sizes consistent across the email, product page, and cart whenever a product’s details change. See the BigCommerce guide to selling pet supplies online for more on selling everyday essentials alongside items customers buy less often.

10 Email Marketing Strategies to Increase Repeat Orders for Pet Stores

These pet store email marketing strategies help customers reorder essentials, find accessories that fit, and manage recurring deliveries.

Set Up Replenishment Emails Before Products Run Out

Time pet food replenishment emails around pack size, buying habits, and how long delivery usually takes. For a 30-day supply with three-day shipping, try sending the reminder on day 25 to leave extra time.

Link directly to the exact item and size they bought, and stop the reminder once they reorder.

Turn First-Time Buyers Into Regular Customers

After delivery, help customers use what they bought, such as showing them how to adjust a harness.

Use ecommerce email marketing flows to follow up with a compatible accessory or reorder reminder once customers have tried their purchase.

Collect Pet Information to Personalize Future Emails

Start your pet care email marketing with an optional question about which pets your customers shop for.

Use Klaviyo segmentation for ecommerce to pair those answers with purchase history and send offers that fit each household.

Recover Abandoned Pet Product Carts

Show shoppers what they left behind, then address a likely concern with ingredients, sizing, or delivery costs.

Use this abandoned cart email timing guide to test when to follow up, and save any discounts for a later email.

Convert Repeat Buyers Into Subscribers

Start pet subscription email marketing with customers who already buy the same food or litter on a regular schedule.

Suggest a delivery frequency close to their usual reorder gap, and show the price, billing dates, and cancellation options.

Reduce Subscription Cancellations With Timely Emails

Remind subscribers before their next order locks, so they have time to change the quantity, skip, or pause.

If customers cancel because they have unopened bags at home, offer a longer gap between deliveries.

Recommend Products That Complement Previous Purchases

In email marketing for pet products, use the last order to suggest something the customer can use with it.

For example, show harness buyers a leash with the right clip or bed buyers a blanket that fits.

Celebrate Pet Birthdays and Adoption Anniversaries

Let customers add or update a pet’s birthday or adoption date, then send a simple reward they can use.

For example, offer a birthday treat with their next eligible order and explain what qualifies and when the offer ends.

Bring Back Customers Who Haven't Ordered Recently

Use each customer’s usual reorder gap to decide when to follow up, especially for products like food and litter.

Link to their previous purchase if it’s available, or ask what stopped them from ordering again if they’re open to sharing.

Build Loyalty Without Relying on Constant Discounts

Increase repeat purchases for pet stores by offering early access, useful bundles, or rewards customers can earn through regular orders.

Track repeat orders and profit after rewards before offering the same benefit to everyone on your list.

Pet Store Email Marketing Examples

These designs show what the customer needs to see first, whether it’s a familiar item or an approaching deadline. Each graphic illustrates the message layout, with source links where a brand has published or documented the underlying campaign.

Personalized Replenishment Reminders

Use the customer’s last order to show the exact recipe and bag size they bought. Send the reminder early enough for the next bag to arrive before they’re likely to run out.

pet food email marketing

Product Education Emails

Send one useful tip soon after delivery, while the customer is getting to know the product. For pet carriers, explain where to find the model number and how to check the dimensions.

email marketing for pet products

Personalized Birthday Campaigns

Use the birthday an owner shared to offer a treat or toy that suits their pet. Put the expiry date and any purchase requirement in the email so shoppers know how to claim it.

pet store email marketing strategies

Pet Food Restock Reminders

Notify customers who asked about an out-of-stock item once their requested size or recipe is available to order. Show the full product name so they can recognize it right away.

pet care email marketing

Subscription Win-Back Emails

Use the customer’s cancellation reason when you have it. If food arrived faster than their pet could finish it, offer a longer gap between deliveries.

pet ecommerce email marketing

Seasonal Subscription Offers

Give shoppers a clear reason to try a seasonal box. Show the first-box price, what each later box costs, and how many deliveries the plan includes.


pet store email marketing

Chewy — Upcoming Autoship Notifications

Chewy’s Autoship reminders show what’s due to ship, what it costs, and when customers can still make changes. Put those details together so subscribers can decide whether to adjust their next delivery.

email marketing for pet brands

Pet Store Email Campaign Ideas for Every Season

Plan seasonal emails around pet-related occasions, weather changes, and shopping events. Promote relevant products, offer seasonal discounts, and suggest items customers may need. Send campaigns early, so shoppers have enough time to place their orders.

Occasion

Campaign Idea

National Pet Day

Customer thank-you email with pet supply bundles

International Cat Day

Cat food, toys, and accessories

International Dog Day

Dog treats and walking essentials

Summer

Travel accessories and cooling products

Winter

Warm beds, blankets, and coats

Halloween

Pet costumes and themed toys

Black Friday

Stock-up offers and bundles

Christmas

Pet gift guides and festive treats

Send pet product email campaigns to shoppers who buy those products, such as cat food buyers for International Cat Day. For holiday offers, send before your shipping cutoff and skip customers who already have the same items on a scheduled delivery.

How to Measure Whether Your Emails Are Bringing Customers Back

Compare customers who first bought during the same period, and give each group equal time to reorder. Review results by product category because litter buyers typically return sooner than customers who bought a pet bed.

  • Repeat Purchases: Calculate the percentage of first-time buyers who order again within a fixed window.
  • Purchase Frequency: Count orders per customer and check how many days usually pass between purchases.
  • Reorder Revenue: Compare sales with a group that received no reminder to estimate additional revenue.
  • Subscription Retention: Track the percentage who renew, and record skips, pauses, cancellations, and failed payments separately.
  • Customer Value: Compare net sales per customer over the same period and account for variable costs.
  • Email Revenue: Divide the revenue credited to each email flow by its number of recipients.

Use customer engagement metrics to investigate gaps, such as many clicks but few orders. When testing an email change, adjust one detail at a time and compare completed orders and profit.

Generate More Repeat Orders With IR Solutions

IR Solutions helps online pet stores find out why first-time buyers drop off and what might bring them back. We review your purchase history, delivery schedules, and existing emails to spot missed reorders and gaps in customer follow-up. Then we set up Klaviyo flows around how customers shop, from replacing a bag of food to managing a subscription.

  • Flow Setup: Build email automation for pet stores and stop refill reminders after reorders.
  • Customer Groups: Use purchase history and pet preferences to send shoppers relevant offers.
  • Subscription Support: Send upcoming shipment reminders with options to adjust, skip, or pause deliveries.
  • Email Design: Write mobile-friendly emails that show the product and make reordering easy.
  • Testing Reports: Test send times and offers, then track repeat orders and email revenue.

Start with a product customers already buy regularly, such as a popular dog food recipe or a particular litter size. We’ll use its reorder history to recommend when to send the first reminder and how to measure the results. Talk to our team about email marketing services for your pet store and discuss which campaigns to build first.

Conclusion

Getting customers to place another order starts with understanding what they buy and when they need it again. Use purchase history to send timely reminders, recommend useful products, and make reordering easier.

For subscriptions, give customers enough flexibility to adjust their delivery schedules. Small changes like these can help reduce cancellations and keep customers coming back.

If you need help building these emails, talk to IR Solutions about your pet store's email marketing. We can help you set up Klaviyo flows that fit your products, delivery schedules, and customers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Email Marketing Effective for Online Pet Stores?

Yes. Pet store email marketing gives customers a timely reminder to reorder food, litter or other supplies. Compare second-order rates between similar groups who received the emails and those who didn’t.

How Can Pet Stores Increase Repeat Purchases Through Email?

Use pet food email marketing to remind customers to reorder while there’s still time for delivery. Link to the exact flavour and pack size they bought, and skip the reminder if they’ve already reordered.

How Often Should Pet Stores Send Marketing Emails?

Start with one campaign a week and leave room for automated emails like refill and subscription reminders. Use sales and unsubscribe rates to see whether sending more often makes sense.

What Are the Best Email Flows for Pet Stores?

Start with welcome emails, abandoned cart reminders, post-purchase emails and reorder reminders. Add back-in-stock alerts or subscription reminders if they suit your store, and check that the emails don’t overlap.

How Can Pet Food Brands Reduce Subscription Cancellations?

Remind customers before the deadline to change their next order. Link directly to settings where they can change the quantity, space out deliveries, skip a shipment or pause the plan.

Is Klaviyo Good for Pet Ecommerce Businesses?

Yes. Klaviyo can send reminders based on what shoppers bought. For example, you can remind someone to restock their dog food after a few weeks and skip the email if they’ve already ordered another bag.

How Can Pet Stores Increase Sales Without Offering Discounts?

Make everyday supplies easy to reorder, offer early access to new products or bundle items customers use together. Track profit after costs to see which offers bring shoppers back and still make money.

Keep reading

Get In Touch
With us

Phone
Select Region

Let’s Build the
Future of Technology Together

pakistan flag

Pakistan (Global Delivery Center)

Office 10, 3rd Floor, Al-Rehmat Plaza G11 Markaz, Islamabad, Pakistan


+92 (335) 5438999
america flag

United States (Regional Office)

INTERACTIVE ROBUST SOLUTIONS LLC 5900 Balcones Drive STE 100 Austin, TX, 78731, USA


+1 (737) 3326312
turkey flag

Türkiye (Regional Office)

Cumhuriyet, İncirli Dedee Cd. floor41 Şişli/İstanbul, Türkiye


+90 (531) 3193533
uae flag

UAE (Regional Office)

Al Jawhara Building 3rd Floor 301 Office 17 1A St - Al Mankhool - Dubai - United Arab Emirates


+971 55 690 2261
telegramwhatsapp